Best Dessert Shops in the New York Theater District
7 Best Places To Get a Sweet Treat in The Theater District in New York City
New York City is known for its diverse food scene, and its desserts are no exception. From classic bakeries to innovative dessert spots, the city offers something for every sweet tooth. Whether you’re a fan of doughnuts, cookies, cakes, or cheesecake, NYC’s got you covered.
We loved that you could find a yummy sweet treat every three steps in NYC. And, after every Broadway show, we searched for something sweet – and we were never disappointed! Here are some of the best places to grab a dessert in the Theater District in New York City:
Magnolia Bakery – THE Place to Get Banana Pudding in New York City
Made famous for its appearance on Sex and the City, Magnolia Bakery is a must-visit spot for anyone in the Theater District. Their cupcakes, mini cheesecakes, and classic baked goods are sure to satisfy any sweet craving. They are most known for their famous banana pudding – you have to try this dessert when you are there!
Near: Radio City Music Hall, Broadway theaters
Magnolia Bakery (Rockefeller Center) // 1240 6th Ave, New York, NY 10020 // 212.767.1123
Bibble & Sip – A New York Bakery Cafe
Bibble & Sip is a cozy bakery that offers a variety of sweet treats. The dessert choices include cream puffs, macarons, and cakes that are made in-house every day. Their desserts are French and Asian-inspired which makes for some delicious and interesting flavor combinations. Their signature dish is the Earl Grey cream puff. It’s a fluffy pastry filled with a creamy Earl Grey tea-infused filling. It is a delicious and unique sweet treat.
Here, you can find top-quality coffees, espresso, and lattes. Even the coffee syrups at Bibble and Sip are made fresh in-house!
Near: Gershwin Theatre, Circle in the Square
Bibble & Sip // 253 West 51 Street – New York, NY 10019 // (646) 649-5116
Carlo’s Bakery
If you’re a fan of the TLC show Cake Boss, you’ll want to check out Carlo’s Bakery on 8th Avenue. The bakery is famous for its elaborate cakes, but they also offer a wide selection of cookies, pastries, and other baked goods.
Carlo’s Bakery // 625 8th Avenue – New York, NY 10018 // 929.446.0509
Masseria Caffe & Bakery
Some Sweet Treats You will Find at Masseria Caffee & Bakery:
- Bombolone -lightly fried doughnut (you can add raspberry, apricot, Nutella, or cream)
- Muffin – blueberry, chocolate chip, or apple crumb
- Girella – brioche dough, cinnamon, raisins (glazed with apricot jam)
- Traditional Italian Sweets – A variety of Italian sweets that change daily
See the full menu HERE.
Near: Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, Al Hirschfeld Theatre
Masseria Caffe & Bakery // 235 West 48th Street – New York City, NY 10036 // (212) 582-2111
Schmackary’s
Schmackary’s is located on West 45th Street, and they specialize in delicious cookies in unique flavors such as Maple Bacon, Funfetti, and Cinnamon Sugar. They offer 75 FLAVORS!!! The bakery also offers gluten-free, nut-free, and vegan options, so everyone can enjoy their treats.
They are open 7 days a week from 9:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Near: Lena Horne Theatre, Richard Rodgers Theatre
Schmackary’s Cookies // 362 West 45th Street – New York, NY 10036 // 646.801.YUMM
Amy’s Bread
Amy’s Bread, located on 9th Avenue (in Hell’s Kitchen), is popular for its artisanal bread and pastries. Patrons love that Amy’s Bread bakes their goodies from scratch with high-quality ingredients. Try anything – croissants, cookies, cupcakes, and danishes. They consider themselves to be a “cross between a Parisian boulangerie and a cozy Midwestern kitchen”.
Near: Booth Theatre, Music Box Theatre
Amy’s Bread // 672 Ninth Avenue (Between 46th & 47th Streets) – New York, NY 10036 // 212.977.2670
Junior’s Restaurant & Bakery – Famous New York Restaurant
Photos Above: We got a Chocolate Cheesecake to go after seeing The Great Gatsby right down the block. Then, we came back another day to try the Fudge Layer Cake. Both were 10/10!
The restaurant has a lovely dining room, outdoor patio dining in the summer, and a full-service bar. In addition to serving some savory dishes like pastrami sandwiches and cheeseburgers, Junior’s serves up some mouthwatering desserts. Try the New York Cheesecake, Chocolate Fudge Layer Cake, and Strawberry Cheese Pie. See the full dessert menu HERE.
Near: Every major Times Square theater
Junior’s Restaurant & Bakery // 1515 Broadway – New York, NY 10036 // 212.302.2000
No matter which bakery you choose to visit in the Theater District, you’re sure to find something delicious to satisfy your sweet tooth. From classic baked goods to unique flavors, these bakeries offer some of the best treats in New York City.
You might also like:
THE 15 BEST PLACES TO GRAB A BURGER IN THE THEATER DISTRICT IN NEW YORK CITY
WHAT EVERY MUSICAL THEATER FAN MUST DO IN NEW YORK CITY
7 BEST ITALIAN RESTAURANTS IN THE THEATER DISTRICT IN NEW YORK CITY
Let's Be Friends! Follow Me:
Related Posts
About The Author
KristyB
Wife. Mom. Graphic Designer. Photographer. Professional Nap Taker. Part-time Traveler (with kids in tow, of course!)
Add a Comment
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
It would be soooo nice to vsiit all these places and get these desserts!
I know, right? No shortage of sweet treats in NYC!
This is an interesting list and some of them are new places to me as well. Would love to visit them soon.
mmm… what a delicious sounding list! My kids would love to take a stop at each.
Mine, too!
Oh wow, It’s a dream come true if I can visit all these places! I love sweets and desserts!
Same, Beth. Same.
All of these spots look fantastic but I would really love to try those mini cheesecakes.
Those were SO GOOD!
Ooohhhh….thank you for sharing about these places. I hadn’t known any of them before! I am bookmarking this blog, for later.
We loved stopping by these places for a late night treat after seeing a show!
Oh my goodness, I’ve been thinking about a trip to New York City and it looks like I need to go just for the dessert!!
Yes! And pack plenty of stretchy pants!
Crazy I’ve lived in NYC and the surrounding areas most of my life and haven’t heard of these dessert places. Thanks for the recommendations.
You’re welcome! You know I love to eat!