7 Best Italian Restaurants in The Theater District in NYC
If you’re looking for a delicious Italian meal in The Theater District of New York City, you’re in luck. This bustling area is home to a variety of Italian restaurants, each with its own unique flair and mouthwatering dishes. From classic pasta dishes to fresh seafood, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
On our recent trip to NYC, we stayed in the Theater District and stayed mostly in the area watching shows. We found pizza shops all over the area, but we also wanted to sit down and enjoy a hot, authentic, Italian meal. We found some wonderful Italian restaurants while we were in town. Here are some of the best Italian restaurants in The Theater District (including Times Square and Hell’s Kitchen) that are definitely worth checking out.
Carmine’s Italian Restaurant
This iconic restaurant has been serving up traditional Italian fare for over 30 years. Carmine’s is known for its huge portions and it has a very lively atmosphere. It’s a great spot for sharing with friends or family. Their spaghetti and meatballs are a must-try dish, as are their signature garlic bread and tiramisu.
Carmine’s Italian Restaurant // 200 West 44th Street – New York, NY 10036 // 212.221.3800
Tony’s Di Napoli (Times Square)
Another classic spot that’s been around for over 50 years, Tony’s Di Napoli is a favorite among locals and tourists alike. Their family-style dining options are perfect for large groups, and the menu is full of classic Italian dishes like chicken parmigiana and linguine with clam sauce. See the full menu HERE.
Tony’s Di Napoli // 147 West 43rd Street – New York, NY 10036 (Between 6th & 7th Ave) // (212) 221-0100
Trattoria Trecolori
This cozy Italian restaurant has been a fixture in The Theater District for over 20 years. Their homemade pasta is the star of the menu, and their Fried Mozzarella appetizer is a must-try. Save room for dessert – their Tiramisu and Mini Cannoli are both delicious.
Trattoria Trecolori // 245 West 47th Street – New York, NY 10036 // 212.977.4540
Barbetta
This elegant restaurant has been serving Italian cuisine since 1906, making it one of the oldest Italian restaurants in New York City. The interior is stunning, with hand-painted murals and a beautiful garden. Their menu is full of Italian classics, and some you may have never tried before (like the Crespelle alla Savoiarda – Italian Crepes, Vegetables, and Bechamel). They even offer a Pre-Theater Dinner on Wednesday through Saturday from 4:30 – 7:00 p.m. It is 4 courses and runs about $63. You can see this menu HERE.
Barbetta // 321 West 46th Street – New York, NY 10036 // 212.246.9171
Osteria al Doge
This charming restaurant serves homemade pasta and Venetian-inspired cuisine. Try the Ravioli Di Ricotta E Spinaci – It’s their homemade spinach and ricotta ravioli in a butter sage sauce and it is divine! You will also find classics like pasta with beef ragu, lasagna, and a variety of pizzas. They also offer gluten-free pasta. The atmosphere is cozy and intimate, with warm lighting and exposed brick walls. Their extensive wine list is a highlight, with plenty of Italian options to choose from.
Osteria al Doge // 142 W. 44th Street NY, NY, 10036 // (212) 944-3643
Becco
Owned by celebrity chef Lidia Bastianich, Becco is a popular Italian restaurant in The Theater District. Their homemade pasta is delicious. Try the Bistecca Di Porterhouse – grilled, dry-aged porterhouse steak served with garlic mashed potatoes and broccoli rabe. Or, order the Galetto ‘Al Forno’ – organic chicken with mushroom risotto and roasted garlic. You can order the three pastas of the day may be added to each individual entrée for $11 – it’s a steal! You can see the full menu HERE.
Becca // 355 West 46th Street – New York, NY 10036 // 212.397.7597
Daniela’s Trattoria
So, last, but not least is Daniela’s Trattoria. This is my daughter’s favorite Italian restaurant in the Theater District. We ate here 3 times on our last trip! It is located near Moulin Rouge, Parade, Life of Pi, and Bad Cinderella (2023). The food is fantastic and the service is friendly and fast. I don’t think we ever waited more than 5 minutes for anything – drinks, bread, entrees, dessert. We never felt rushed but we also never worried about being late to a Broadway show because of slow service!
Daniela’s Trattoria // 728 8th Avenue (between 45th and 46th) – New York, NY 10036 // 212.869.3585
The Theater District in New York City is a great place to satisfy your craving for Italian cuisine. And, if you’re looking for a warm, hearty meal before seeing a Broadway show, these restaurants are a must-visit. From classic spots like Tony’s Di Napoli and Carmines Italian Restaurant to newer, trendier places like Osteria al Doge, there’s something for everyone. So next time you’re in the area, be sure to check out these delicious Italian restaurants.
You Might Also Enjoy:
The 15 BEST Places to Grab a Burger in the Theater District in New York City
Related Posts
About The Author
KristyB
Wife. Mom. Graphic Designer. Photographer. Professional Nap Taker. Part-time Traveler (with kids in tow, of course!)